Starting a thread on this because it keeps coming up in ones and twos: The three questions I took to my review
I have read the paper and I am not sure I have understood it.
I want to be careful about how I phrase this because I am not accusing anybody of anything. I am asking what a document actually establishes.
I would like to know what the best single piece of human evidence is, because I suspect the honest answer is thinner than the discussion suggests.
To put the figure in the title beside the rest of it: three questions. That is the whole of the arithmetic and none of it is an estimate.
I will summarise whatever the thread concludes and add it to my notes, in case it is useful to somebody later.
35